Manorama Six Feet Under

Rating: 4/4 (Edge-of-the-seat film noir in Hindi!)

Thanks to the growth of multiplexes there has been a slew of small to mid budget movies coming out of Bollywood in the last few years. I find that most of them are refreshingly different from the usual SRK-song-dance crap. One example of a budget gem is Manorama Six Feet Under. The movie is shot like a Hollywood film noir, could be the first Hindi movie of this kind. The setting is ideal: a government engineer stuck in a small town somewhere in dusty Rajasthan. He writes pulp fiction as a side hobby! One night his creations come to life when a woman shows up at his door claiming to be a fan of his work and requests him to solve a case. He gets involved in and it pulls him into a strange whirlpool of events.

Full marks to the writing and script in Manorama. The suspense is great, I was on the edge wondering what would happen next right upto the end. There is excellent dark humour all through, something that I sorely miss in Hindi movies. The casting is apt, newcomer Abhay Deol plays the writer and Gul Panag plays his suspecting wife to perfection. The cinematography of empty desert places and the night scenes really suits the noir style of the movie. With not a single boring moment, Manorama Six Feet Under is a delightful clever gem which is sure to gain some sort of cult following with time.

The Inheritance Of Loss

I borrowed my flatmate’s The Inheritance Of Loss for the weekend read. This book by Kiran Desai won the 2006 Booker. Set in the 1980s in Kalimpong (this is distant Himalayan India, where India blurs into Bhutan and Sikkim) the story is mainly about 3 eccentric characters — a retired judge, his granddaughter Sai and his servile cook. While Desai goes about deliciously setting the life stories of these characters and their friends in breathtakingly beautiful Kalimpong through flashbacks and forwards, the region itself slowly falls into chaos due to the Nepalese-Indian demand for a separate nation/state of Gorkhaland. And this movement rips apart their bucolic lives revealing how gray and vulnerable they all are.

The book is lovely, the setting is beautiful and the characters remain etched forever. The prose strongly reminds me of R K Narayan and Enid Blyton. In describing the idyllic setting of Cho Oyu (the judge’s home which overlooks the mighty Kanchenjunga) and Kalimpong, I’m strongly reminded of Blyton (even Ruskin Bond) and her rustic settings. In the characters and their confusing mess of lives (like most of us), it is Narayan who shows through. I can’t help but feel that Kalimpong and it’s residents share a lot with Malgudi. It feels nostalgic of a time gone by in our childhood.

The narrative is not linear, it keeps going backward and forward. Desai takes her time in revealing the details about the 3 interesting characters in the book. It’s one of the reasons the books really pulled me in, titillating all the time, to know one more bit about the judge or Sai, to understand why they are what they are in the current time. There’s this whole parallel narrative about Biju, the cook’s son who’s an illegal immigrant in NYC. IMO the book could’ve done without this entire arc.

The story takes a whole plethora of tones: British Raj, nationalism, love, hate, economic/social disparities, nature and so on. The characters seem innocent at first, but as more about their past is revealed and their lives become affected by the Gorkhaland movement, we discover they’re mortal too, with all kinds of gray. Full marks to Desai for bringing this about well. All the main characters have lost something in the past, and the sad part is that (this novel doesn’t have much of a happy ending) they won’t gain it back. I almost felt a bit of hate for Desai, for she slowly pulls apart their happy lives into a tragic puddle.

Terrific prose and setting, unforgettable characters, but a bit tragic. Recommended read. (4/5)

Related: Jabberwock’s 2006 and 2007 interviews with Kiran Desai.